Testimony in Opposition to SB12

Testimony in Opposition to SB 12, A Proposal for a Legislative Amendment to the Constitution of the Commonwealth relative to the subject matter of initiative petition

Joint Committee on the Judiciary
April 14, 2011

As a public policy organization, Massachusetts Family Institute strongly opposes Senate Bill 12 to amend Article 48 to not allow any initiative petition that would restrict the rights set forth in the state constitution to freedom and equality, or the right of each individual to be protected by society in the enjoyment of life, liberty and property, according to standing laws.

Article 48 was passed during the Constitutional Convention of 1918 under the much heralded progressive movement of the era to give the people a more active role in government. Since that time, hundreds of Legislative Amendments have been proposed, many of which reached the ballot and were passed by the voters. But only 13 Initiative Amendments by the people have successfully passed the significant hurdle of collecting tens of thousands of signatures from registered voters. Of the thirteen attempts, only three were approved by the Legislature to be on the ballot, and of those three, two were approved by the voters in a general election. In 1938 the people voted by 42% to 23% to create biennial sessions of the legislature. In 1974 the people voted to allow the use of highway tax funds for mass transit.

Based on the results of the past 93 years, it is preposterous to claim that the initiative petition process in Massachusetts is too easy and a threat to individual rights. In fact, Massachusetts has the most cumbersome and complicated initiative petition process in the nation, accentuated by the requirement of the Legislature to approve the proposed amendment in two separate legislative sessions before it can be on the ballot. No other state has this requirement. Placing a proposed amendment before the people through an initiative process is so prohibitively difficult in Massachusetts that the process has rarely, if ever, been used.

Why would the Legislature want to make the initiative petition process even more difficult by excluding any subject dealing with freedom, equality, life, liberty or property, “according to standing laws?” Such a limitation would apply to almost any topic thereby effectively taking away the right of citizens to amend their constitution. This is clearly an overreach attempt by certain legislators and special interest groups to throttle the voice and rights of the people.

Please reject this proposed Legislative Amendment to Article 48 of the Constitution.

Sincerely,

Kris Mineau
President

Share:

More Posts

Crisis in the Classroom: Escalating Violence and Indoctrination in MA Public Schools

MA public schools are becoming increasingly unsafe for students. Instances of violence, alongside the troubling trends of sexualization and indoctrination of children, raise profound concerns regarding the health and safety of youth attending government schools in the Commonwealth. According to the Student Discipline Data Report on the MA Department of Elementary and

MFI Protects Pro-Life Pharmacist

Did you know that state and federal laws require employers to offer reasonable accommodations for the religious beliefs of their employees? A pro-life pharmacist who works at a national pharmacy chain recently reached out to MFI for help. Her pharmacy has started providing the abortion pill to customers. But due

Opting Out of LGBTQ Content in School – The Problem and What Parents Can Do About It

It’s no secret that students in Massachusetts public schools are inundated with content promoting sexual activity, alternate sexual orientations, and sexual and gender confusion. We sounded the alarm last year on the new Health Curriculum Frameworks, which tell schools to push dangerous and destructive sexual ideologies onto kids from the youngest ages.

Register Now for MFI’s Reclaiming Education Conference

You are cordially invited to MFI’s Reclaiming Education Conference, a groundbreaking event hosted in collaboration with the Herzog Foundation!  Are you a parent who needs an affordable option to the public school system? Are you a pastor or church leader who desires to expand your ministry to the families in your